FDA-Approved Treatments Only
Back to Articles
Guides

Best Appetite Suppressant in 2024: Prescription & Natural Options Compared

Compare the most effective appetite suppressants available, from GLP-1 medications to prescription pills and natural alternatives. Learn what works and what doesn't.

11 min read
December 5, 2024
American Made GLP-1 Editorial Team
Best Appetite Suppressant in 2024: Prescription & Natural Options Compared

If constant hunger is sabotaging your weight loss efforts, you're not alone. Appetite suppressants—from powerful prescription medications to natural options—can help. Here's an honest look at what's available and what actually works.

Understanding Appetite Suppressants

Appetite suppressants work through different mechanisms:

  • Hormonal: Mimic or enhance satiety hormones (GLP-1s)
  • Neurological: Affect brain chemistry to reduce hunger signals (stimulants)
  • Mechanical: Create physical fullness (fiber, volume)
  • Metabolic: Affect how the body processes nutrients

Prescription Appetite Suppressants: The Most Effective Options

1. GLP-1 Receptor Agonists (Most Effective)

These are currently the most powerful appetite suppressants available:

Semaglutide (Wegovy, Ozempic)

  • How it works: Mimics GLP-1 hormone, signals fullness to brain
  • Average weight loss: 15-17% of body weight
  • Administration: Weekly injection
  • Cost: $900-1,500/month (without insurance)
  • Effectiveness rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Tirzepatide (Mounjaro, Zepbound)

  • How it works: Dual GLP-1 and GIP receptor activation
  • Average weight loss: 20-25% of body weight
  • Administration: Weekly injection
  • Cost: $900-1,500/month (without insurance)
  • Effectiveness rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Why GLP-1s Lead the Pack

GLP-1 medications don't just suppress appetite—they fundamentally change how your brain responds to food. Many users describe it as "food noise" going quiet for the first time.

2. Phentermine (Adipex-P, Lomaira)

  • How it works: Stimulates nervous system, releases norepinephrine
  • Average weight loss: 5-10% of body weight
  • Administration: Daily pill
  • Duration: FDA-approved only for short-term use (12 weeks)
  • Cost: $30-75/month (generic)
  • Effectiveness rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

3. Qsymia (Phentermine + Topiramate)

  • How it works: Combines stimulant + anticonvulsant effects
  • Average weight loss: 8-10% of body weight
  • Administration: Daily pill
  • Cost: $150-250/month
  • Effectiveness rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

4. Contrave (Bupropion + Naltrexone)

  • How it works: Affects reward pathways and cravings
  • Average weight loss: 5-8% of body weight
  • Administration: Daily pills (2 twice daily)
  • Cost: $100-250/month
  • Best for: Emotional eaters, those with cravings
  • Effectiveness rating: ⭐⭐⭐
MedicationWeight LossFormCost/MonthRating
Tirzepatide20-25%Injection$900-1,500Best
Semaglutide15-17%Injection$900-1,500Excellent
Qsymia8-10%Pill$150-250Very Good
Phentermine5-10%Pill$30-75Good
Contrave5-8%Pill$100-250Moderate

Natural Appetite Suppressants

While not as powerful as prescription options, some natural approaches can help:

Evidence-Based Options

Fiber Supplements

  • How they work: Expand in stomach, create physical fullness
  • Best types: Glucomannan, psyllium husk
  • Effectiveness: Modest—1-3 pounds more than placebo
  • Cost: $10-30/month
  • Rating: ⭐⭐⭐

Protein

  • How it works: Most satiating macronutrient
  • Target: 25-30g per meal
  • Best sources: Lean meats, eggs, Greek yogurt
  • Effectiveness: Meaningful reduction in hunger
  • Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Coffee/Caffeine

  • How it works: Mild stimulant, temporary appetite suppression
  • Amount: 1-2 cups before meals
  • Effectiveness: Short-term; tolerance develops
  • Rating: ⭐⭐

Green Tea Extract

  • How it works: Caffeine + catechins
  • Effectiveness: Very modest
  • Rating: ⭐⭐

Overhyped Options (Skip These)

  • Garcinia cambogia: Studies show minimal effect
  • Raspberry ketones: No human evidence
  • Most "fat burners": Little to no proof they work
  • Hoodia: Doesn't work as claimed

Reality Check

Natural appetite suppressants can provide mild support, but don't expect dramatic results. If weight loss were as simple as taking a supplement, obesity wouldn't be such a widespread problem. Prescription options are more effective for a reason.

Behavioral "Appetite Suppressants"

These strategies don't involve pills but can reduce appetite:

Water Timing

  • Drink 16oz water 30 minutes before meals
  • Creates mechanical fullness
  • Studies show modest reduction in meal size

Sleep

  • Sleep deprivation increases hunger hormones
  • 7-9 hours associated with lower appetite
  • Poor sleep can undo other efforts

Stress Management

  • Cortisol increases cravings
  • Chronic stress promotes overeating
  • Meditation, exercise can help

Meal Timing

  • Eating protein at breakfast reduces later hunger
  • Regular meals prevent extreme hunger
  • Some people do well with intermittent fasting

Choosing the Right Option

Consider GLP-1s If:

  • You have significant weight to lose (BMI 30+ or 27+ with conditions)
  • You can afford the cost or have insurance coverage
  • You're comfortable with injections
  • You want the most effective option available

Consider Phentermine/Qsymia If:

  • You need a more affordable option
  • You prefer pills over injections
  • You need help getting started (short-term boost)
  • You can't access GLP-1 medications

Consider Natural Options If:

  • You have mild appetite issues
  • You prefer non-prescription approaches
  • You're supplementing other strategies
  • You have contraindications to medications

What to Avoid

Red Flags in Appetite Suppressants

  • Unregulated supplements: Unknown ingredients, contamination risk
  • "Miracle" claims: If it sounds too good to be true...
  • Hidden stimulants: Some supplements contain unlisted stimulants
  • Multi-level marketing products: Usually overpriced and underperforming
  • Imported pills online: Quality control concerns

Safety Warning

The FDA has found dangerous ingredients (including prescription drugs and banned substances) in many over-the-counter weight loss supplements. Stick to reputable sources and FDA-approved medications.

The Future of Appetite Control

New options are coming:

  • Retatrutide: Triple hormone receptor agonist in trials
  • Oral semaglutide: Pill version already available (Rybelsus)
  • AMG 133: New mechanism in development
  • CagriSema: Semaglutide + amylin combination

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the strongest appetite suppressant?

Currently, tirzepatide (Mounjaro/Zepbound) appears to be the most effective, followed closely by semaglutide (Wegovy/Ozempic). Both dramatically reduce appetite and lead to significant weight loss.

Are appetite suppressants safe?

FDA-approved options (GLP-1s, phentermine, Qsymia, Contrave) are generally safe when prescribed appropriately. Side effects vary by medication. Work with a healthcare provider who can monitor you.

Can I take appetite suppressants long-term?

GLP-1 medications, Qsymia, and Contrave are approved for long-term use. Phentermine is technically approved only for short-term use (12 weeks), though some doctors prescribe it longer off-label.

What's the best natural appetite suppressant?

Protein is probably the most effective "natural" appetite suppressant. Fiber supplements like glucomannan can also help modestly. But don't expect dramatic results from natural options.

Will I gain weight back when I stop?

Usually some weight returns when any appetite suppressant is stopped, as appetite returns to baseline. This is why many people use these medications long-term and why building healthy habits alongside medication is important.

Why is my appetite so strong?

Appetite is controlled by complex hormonal and neural systems. Genetics, previous dieting, sleep, stress, and metabolic factors all play roles. Some people genuinely have stronger hunger signals—it's not just willpower.

Conclusion

The best appetite suppressant depends on your situation, health status, budget, and goals. GLP-1 medications are the most effective but most expensive. Older options like phentermine are less effective but more affordable. Natural options provide modest support at best.

Whatever you choose, work with a healthcare provider to find the right approach for your individual needs. Appetite suppression is a legitimate tool for weight loss—there's no shame in using medications when diet and exercise alone aren't enough.

Key Takeaway

If strong appetite is your main weight loss obstacle, modern medications—especially GLP-1s—can make a dramatic difference. Don't waste money on unproven supplements when effective prescription options exist.

Ready to Get Started?

Compare providers offering the most effective appetite-suppressing medications.

Compare Top GLP-1 Providers →

appetite suppressantweight lossmedicationGLP-1phenterminenatural supplements
Top Rated

Top GLP-1 Providers

Get started with America's most trusted programs

CoreAge Rx

Editor's Choice

Premium GLP-1 Weight Loss Program

4.9
LegitScript Certified
#2

Ro

Editor's Choice

December Sale: Get Started Online for Just $45

4.8
LegitScript Certified
#3

Hers

Best for Women

Monthly Plans Starting at $69/Mo

4.7
LegitScript Certified

Medical Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare provider before starting any weight loss program or medication. Individual results may vary. American Made GLP-1 is a comparison website and does not provide medical services.